Cannonball Read IV

A bunch of Pajibans reading and reviewing and honoring AlabamaPink.

genericwhitegirl’s #CBR4 Review #6: Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children by Ransom Riggs

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, kids are creepy. What can take a horror movie to the next level? A creepy kid. Remember the kids in The Shining? That boy who would make his finger talk and say “redrum” over and over? Or those twin girls? What about The Others? Or The Sixth Sense? Or all those other movies I haven’t seen because they have creepy kids in them and I’m too scared to watch them? Who doesn’t agree that dolls are creepy? And why were garbage pail kids so popular back in the day? Creepy kids. Has anyone seen the teletubbies? Weirdest shit I’d ever seen.

Having said all that, what drew me to this book was the eerie picture of a girl floating on the cover. The picture looks real, and it looks old. Which brings me to another creepy device…old stuff. And this is a black and white photo, so it’s old. At least, it looks old. After I did some asking around, I realized the book’s premise is based on several photos that the author obtained. They are an eclectic bunch of pictures, many of which involve amateur photo tricks like the picture of the girl floating on the cover. Some of the photos don’t involve any kind of trick, per se, but they’re just strange, out of context images. And a lot of them involve kids. Creepy kids. Riggs uses these photos as inspiration for his story, and every now and then, he’ll describe a character or a scene, and voila! On the next page is a picture of just what he is describing.

So what’s the deal? The story is about Jacob, a teenager who has grown up hearing strange stories from his grandfather, who fled to Wales during WWII. His grandfather grows up in a home with other children, who are all special in some way. Set in modern times, Jacob finds himself delving into his grandfather’s past and visiting the orphanage to better understand the strange tales he heard growing up. Although the orphanage and its inhabitants are from the 1940’s, Jacob finds a way to connect with his grandfather’s past.

It’s difficult to get more detailed without giving anything away. But the book is basically a mix of X-Men/sci-fi/fantasy all in one. My reaction to the book was a little mixed…as it is with creepy kids in general. I’m a bit put off, but intrigued at the same time. Although I was more intrigued than put off in this case. I felt the incorporation of the photos was creative, but contrived at times. I could see the author thinking, “How do I get this photo into my narrative?” and then making up a random scene just to make it work. That took me out of the story a couple of times, but I was still excited to see what photo would be next and it definitely made the tale more visual for me. The story definitely fits a young adult genre though, which I find (except in a few cases) can dilute the potential of a story (if that makes any sense to anyone other than myself).

I agree with many others who have reviewed this book – the pictures are creepier than the story itself; and the tale is somewhat immature and underdeveloped.  But despite the mixed feelings, if you like fantasy stories or are a YA fan, you may get a kick out of this one.

Read The Blist for more reviews by genericwhitegirl.

Single Post Navigation

2 thoughts on “genericwhitegirl’s #CBR4 Review #6: Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children by Ransom Riggs

  1. sevenstories on said:

    Apologies if I am misunderstanding your point, but I think I disagree with you about the YA genre diluting the potential of a story. YA is a totally different genre and has different criteria, they’re not just less well developed or simple stories. Yes there is a lot of really bad, simplistic YA out there, but there is also some really bad adult fiction out there too. And some YA is flat out awesome, but this stuff is still YA – it doesn’t become anything else when it is complex and well written. It is a definite genre, and many adults won’t enjoy reading it just as we all like reading different genres, I’m not saying everyone has to read and enjoy it but stories can be told just as magically and wonderfully and carefully in YA as in any other genre.

  2. I think we actually agree with each other…Young adult fiction CAN be complex and well-developed. But a lot of the ones I’ve read recently have fallen short of that. The stories, at their heart, are great, interesting tales. But the execution of them has left me disappointed. I might have incorrectly implied that if those disappointing YA stories met their full potential, they would no longer fall in the YA genre. Thanks for commenting!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.