Cannonball Read IV

A bunch of Pajibans reading and reviewing and honoring AlabamaPink.

narfna’s #CBR4 Review #39: The Girl Who Circumnavigated Fairyland in a Ship of Her Own Making by Catherynne M. Valente

Dudes, it’s been waaay too long since I read this book. This review is not going to be my best ever. (I am SO BEHIND in my reviews. For instance, this is my 39th review, but I am currently reading my 46th and 47th books. I’m sure this is a problem a lot of you are having as well. Please take this opportunity to whine in my comments. I will not mind.)

The Girl Who Circumnavigated Fairyland in a Ship of Her Own Making (longest title EVER, so good thing it’s so adorable) came to me very highly recommended from several sources, so I was extremely excited to read it. I even bought myself a shiny hardcover copy. I’m happy to say I enjoyed it very much, although it wasn’t as great as I was hoping it would be.

TGWCFiaSoHWM (!) is about a little girl called September who is spirited away to Fairyland one day for an adventure. She traverses Fairyland with an assortment of magical creatures and beasts, including her very own Wyverary (his mother was a Wyvern, and his father a library). She also encounters a woman made of soap, a town made of cloth, a herd of wild bicycles, and a race of half-people that I’m frankly at a loss to explain. Sure there’s an “evil queen” figure propelling her into all sorts of scrapes, and little whiffs of destiny here and there, but ultimately, it’s September herself who charts her own course around Fairyland and comes out the other side.

TGWCFiaSoHWM is charming and whimsical, and extremely imaginative, but for most of the book, it is a little light on character development. Valente packs so much imagination into her world-building that it’s breathtaking, and her sentences are frankly magical, but she spends far less time on the creations that populate this fantastical universe she’s created. For that reason, until the end of the book, reading TGWCFiaSoHWM felt like a bit of a shallow experience. All frosting, no cake. And other such metaphors.

And then the ending happened.

Until I read the ending, I was all set and ready to give the book three stars. And then the ending kind of knocked me on my ass. I won’t go into details, but suffice it to say that all the emotion and character depth that was missing throughout most of the book was packed into its last hurrah. The story of The Marquess was devastatingly sad and horrible in the best way possible. It made me rethink the whole rest of the book. I actually think this book would have been much oomphier with The Marquess as the main character, or with her story as a framing device or something. Something to let you know that September isn’t the real show here, that her journey into Fairyland signifies something more important when seen through the lens of The Marquess’s story at the end of the book.

But then again, this isn’t my story, it’s Valente’s, and her heroine is September. Anyway, the ending was awesome even though I think she could have worked it into the rest of the story somehow, so I’m giving this like 3.75 stars, but I’ll round up to 4 just because I’m feeling magnanimous.

[Cross-posted to Goodreads.]

Single Post Navigation

9 thoughts on “narfna’s #CBR4 Review #39: The Girl Who Circumnavigated Fairyland in a Ship of Her Own Making by Catherynne M. Valente

  1. sevenstories on said:

    I really want to read this having seen a couple of great reviews on CBR4 but it doesn’t seem to be available on Amazon UK, only one expensive used copy and a pre-order for the Kindle. Hopefully it will become more widely available here soon.

    Also, amen to the frustrations of being behind in your reviews, I’m in the same boat. It makes it way harder to write interesting and relevant reviews I find but don’t want to slow down on the reading just to catch up with reviews. I keep saying I should write shorter reviews but I find it hard to be concise!

    • Amen to your last two points. I’ve found that the only way I get my reviews done is if I hold myself hostage. Like, you can’t read any more of this book until you write at least two reviews! At the moment I’m holding myself hostage until I can write five. We’ll see how that works out.

      Hope you can track down a copy of this book. It really is worth it!

  2. baxlala on said:

    I am also behind on writing reviews…I think there are a few books I’m just not going to review (Fables, etc) because I can’t remember what happened in each one individually. Wah waaaaaah.

  3. I feel immensely proud that this year (with a few exceptions – like NOW), I’ve managed to keep more or less on top of my reviews. Last year, I was frequently 8 or 9 books behind all the time, and it made it SO hard to do good reviews.

    The reading is never the hard part of Cannonball, the reviewing is.

    • I’ve been pretty good up until now, but I keep finishing books and things keep getting in the way, and now I’m seven reviews behind. It feels awful.

  4. This sounds so interesting, and Amazon recommends this for ages 10 and up, and for readers who like Narnia and Roald Dahl. What do you think? Could I read this with my kids (who are under 10)? Or is it for a more mature reader? I’d love any feedback on this. Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.